Yellow card in International Matches

Post Reply

Choose an option for International matches

Poll ended at 11/10/2017, 9:44

Solution 1: U21 matches are competitive. + solves the U21 bans problem - Senior team bans always decrease
Solution 2: Cards on U21 matches do not count for bans. + Senior team is correct - Never a ban in U21
Solution 3: The system is ok as it is
No votes
Total votes: 26
Ian Foletto
Posts: 3426
Joined: 08/01/2009, 9:44

Yellow card in International Matches

Post by Ian Foletto » 04/10/2017, 9:44

As a few users reported and enquired about, I've had a close look on how to solve the issue about International bans, in particular for U21 players.

How things stand.
The actual problem is that if an U21 player is banned, and the Senior International team has been knocked out of the world cup, bans never decrease, as U21 matches are treated by the system as "non competitive" and therefore they are not useful for bans, and the team is treated by the engine as a whole (Senior+U21 team) and it cannot be split.

There is not a simple solution, as every solution is not "ideal". It has to be decided which is the best (or less bad...).

Solution 1: We tell the match engine that also U21 World cup is "competitive". So that bans will decrease. What may happen though is that the other way round can happen. If a nation is still in U21 WC, but the senior team has been knocked out, senior team bans will decrease even if they're only playing a friendly. That is because the system treats the team as a whole and if one of the team has a competitive match, the whole squad is treated as such. So it solves the problem we have, but is a little not realistic for 1st teams.

Solution 2: We tell the match engine that cards on U21 World Cup matches does not count like it happens for friendlies. That might be not ideal as well, as it would mean that there won't be any U21 bans ever and is not really realistic, but on the other side it prevents the actual problem and the 1st team is not affected like it happens in solution 1.

Solution 3: Everything stays as it is now, as you don't feel the actual system is a problem.
Steven McCarthy
Posts: 2714
Joined: 09/01/2009, 17:47

Re: Yellow card in International Matches

Post by Steven McCarthy » 04/10/2017, 10:07

Think solution 1 is the one everybody would be happy with
Trophy cabinet

Premier league (s21, s22, s23 & s24)
A1 (s12 & s30)
B2 (s11)
ITN Cup (s22 & s23)
Prem Cup (s13 s14, s21 & s22)
Champions Cup (s23 & s35)
World Cup (s24 & s34)
World Cup U21 (s29)
Manager Of Season (s22 & s23)
Warren Freimanis
Posts: 1588
Joined: 09/01/2009, 10:41
Location: Swansea, Wales

Re: Yellow card in International Matches

Post by Warren Freimanis » 04/10/2017, 15:05

What new features will we see in the new season Ian? Any news on the game face lift as discussed ages ago?
Manager of Everton FC & France
User avatar
Neil Roberts
Posts: 2094
Joined: 07/12/2008, 23:34

Re: Yellow card in International Matches

Post by Neil Roberts » 10/10/2017, 0:32

Solution 3 isn't a solution so that's out lol.

I think solution 1 is the best way to go, it isn't perfect but u21 matches should probably count as competitive anyway.
Neil Roberts
The Blades!!!
Post Reply